We loved Marina Cay. We had a villa and could sit and watch the turtles in the water in the mornings. Marina Cay does cater to the yachting crowd, but we were there for only a two night stay and we loved it. The price of the room includes a very nice breakfast. We had great snorkeling right off the... more

We share all the same sentiments of the previous ( April 10) review of Marina Cay. We have traveled to other islands in the Carribean, Mexico, Hawaii, and Tahiti and found Marina Cay to be one of the best trips we've ever taken. Alison, we love you! From the warn hug when we arrived, to all the wonderful suggestions on... more

We have just returned from Marina Cay after staying a week in Villa 1 -- Jasmine -- and we loved every minute we were there. When we walked in the room it literally took our breath away, the view is so spectacular. The villa is totally open, and the breeze is always fresh, and you just can't get enough of... more

We stayed at Marina Cay in a double room from 18th March for 5 nights. We booked initially based on the great reviews on Tripadvisor and also on the look of the hotel and island on the company website. The negative review recently posted about Marina Cay did make us nervous as we read it a few days before we... more

We chose Marina Cay based on all the trip advisor reviews! What a disappointment. Alison, the manager, was harried and too busy socializing with her yacht friends to provide any of the personal touches described in previous reviews. I was there with my wife, my sister and brother-in-law, and my father. The four of us stayed in one of the... more

Marina Cay is absolutely the BEST! We had a wonderful one week stay of relaxation and fun in the sun! Allison, the hotel/island manager, made our stay PERFECT!!! From the 1st contact to book the stay throughout the entire week she surpassed ALL expectations!! She had beach toys galore for our little girl and bent over backwards to make sure... more

Bottom Line is it's terrific, not too upscale, very intimate and cozy with very good people, facilities, beach, and food, We spent 6 nights and they had to tear us away we loved it so. First two nights were in one of 4 singles. Great view and private view, clean and comfortable but not very big and the shower is... more

Our 12 day stay at this jewel island was fantastic. The beautiful tiny 8 acre island is surrounded by a coral reef making the crystal clear waters warm and calm. With only 6 rooms available and very few people it seems like you are on your own private island. Yachters flock to the famous Pusser's restaurant at night to enjoy... more

Marina Cay is exactly what they described themselves as. It is a private island that caters to the sailing crowd. We stayed for a couple of nights in a deluxe room. The room was very cute and we loved the balcony and the view from the room. The bed is very comfortable! There were virtually no bugs even though we... more