I found Exotic Caye Beach Resort to be rustic and quaint. Although not posh, the staff more than makes up for that. I arrived to have Evalee know who I was immediately and call me by name. She and Rose were always there when I needed something or wanted to make reservations for an activity. Ali was at Crazy Canucks... more

We stayed at Exotic Caye beach resort from 2/24/08 to 3/2/08. We stayed in a Standard 1-bedroom, unit 5A (ground level); our friends were in 4A (deluxe 2-bedroom) and 5B (standard 1-bedroom). Everyone was extremely happy with our accomodations. Our unit was mostly hidden behind lush tropical foliage, yet we had a wonderful cooling breeze when sitting on our porch.... more

They told us that they were a 3 star resort with a 5 star attitude and they lived up to their promise. The 2-bedroom villa came complete with a full kitchen and dining area and suited our needs perfectly. When we weren't taking advantage of the superb diving, we enjoyed the Crazy Canuck Bar onsite or the Roadkill Bar across... more

Exotic Caye is in much need of repair. A list of pros and cons as follows: Pros: Monkey Bites Cafe a real treat for breakfast and lunch, staff very friendly. The bar located on beach, great drinks and staff. Rooms are clean. Cons: Peeling paint and rotten wood on trim and railings. Ants in living/kitchen and bathroom (spray provided by... more

Our vacation was to be from December 24, 2007 through January 3, 2008 and after 3 days we wanted out. The kitchen had ants, our bedroom had ants, and we had ants in our bed. The appliances did not work. The pool was plastic and it's surrond was coming apart. The resort outdoor lounge furniture consisted of two broken wooden... more

I am late in posting this review, but I remember the island and condo like it was yesterday. The island was everything we were looking for...no crowds, no all-inclusives, no traffic, beautiful and serene. The flight from Belize City was smooth and easy, finding a taxi there is no problem. We stayed in a one bedroom (booked directly through the... more

This was a perfect place to relax and get away from the crowds. Don't go if you want mall shopping and disco dancing. The front office people were very helpful, polite and happy. The Crazy Canuck's very entertaining and the bartenders the best! The dive dock would accommodate any request. The rooms and grounds are immaculate. The weather in April... more

We stayed at Exotic Caye from July 9th through July 16th. Check in was smooth and easy. Room was nice and spacious. It had a nice kitchen with a fridge, coffee maker, microwave, and everything you needed to cook there. The grounds of the resort were well kept and quiet. Never used the pool, but it was always being cleaned.... more

We recently stayed at the Exotic Caye for 10 days. We were with another couple and had a great time. Our rooms were the deluxe condos on the second floor and they were great! They were large with a seperate large bedroom and we had an upstairs loft and another bathroom upstairs. The floor was tiled and the whole place... more