What a great find! The Island City House staff was very welcoming and our suite was wonderful. We stayed in the cigar house, with a full kitchen and balcony deck. The bed was comfortable and breakfast in the garden was great. We rented bicycles from the hotel and toured Key West--the only way to go! We were not able to... more

Stayed here for 1 night and it was amazing! Full kitchen, living room, full bath with tub, bathroom with a full size closet and 2 flat screen TVs. The place was very well designed and tastefully decorated. We found no faults in this establishment and will stay here the next time we visit Key West. Also comes with Continental Breakfast.... more

We stayed here on the weekend of the April 26, 2008. We were instantly impressed when we walked in to the suite. It was huge! There were 2 flat screen tv's and it was immaculate. The daily breakfast was good and the staff was VERY friendly. We personally did not have any issues with parking. We highly recommend this B+B. more

If you're looking for a tranquil, relaxing place that's near Duval St and the Bight, the Island City House is great. This was a beautiful bed & breakfast style property. My wife and I stayed for 5 nights in the Cigar House. We had a 3rd floor room with hardwood floors throughout and a private balcony facing the pool. It... more

We stayed for 4 nights in the Arch House and found it an excellent relaxing place. The room was spacious, with a kitchenette, HD TV, balcony overlooking the palm trees, sofa and a comfortable bed. The breakfast was pleasant enough (croissants, fruit etc) in the nice courtyard. The pool was smallish but nice and quiet. The area is great -... more

The Island City House Hotel may be the oldest operating guesthouse on Key West, but it is spotless and modern! We were very pleased with our accommodations in the carriage house. The two-bedroom suite gave us the authentic Key West experience we were looking for. It felt like our own place! We had no interest in staying in a chain... more

We stayed two nights here last Dec. It was fairly quiet, although our room in the Arch House was on the street side of the building. There are several good places to eat within walking distance, and we never actually used the car at all. Which is good, because parking was very difficult to find. The breakfast was average, but... more

Great find! The rooms are historic, but still quite modern. The ONLY exception is the terrible cable TV service. They had two modern flat screen TVs in my room, but the cable picture was all snowy. This hotel should switch to satellite or get a repairman out there. It's terrible. The included breakfast was fantastic. Served in the courtyard. The... more

Just returned last night from Key West. We stayed at the Island City House and really enjoyed our stay. The property is located on a quiet street just three short blocks from the noise and crowds of Duval Street. The gardens are very lush and pretty. Our room was very quaint and charming. The staff was nice and helpful. The... more