This hotel was very accomodating for our family trip in August. I booked the hotel through hotels.com for a non-smoking room. When we arrived we were given a smoking room. I explained to the manager that I booked a non smoking room, due to my husband's allergies to smoke. The Manager of the hotel told me he didn't have any... more

After reading many reviews, I booked this hotel for my husband and I and another couple. We loved this hotel!. We had a view of Manhattan from the hotel window. The rooms were clean and the decor was quite modern and updated. The double beds were comfortable. The TV was a flat screen mounted on the wall. The room was... more

My family and I booked a room for a Saturday night. Apparently the hotel allows locals to throw parties in their conference rooms on Saturday nights. When we went to check out the next morning I found that the hood on my car had been dented and there were strange fluids on the hood as well. We assumed that some... more

I booked this hotel on Best Western's site. The internet rate was fantastic! What a deal. Online while booking I requested a room at the end of the hallway with a NYC view, they gave me exactly this. Spacious, modern and clean was my immediate reaction to our room. Bathroom was large (even with a motion detector light *bonus) Flat... more

Robert Treat Hotel is very convenient to Newark International airport, and Newark Penn Station. They run a shuttle to both places on a regular basis. It is very convenient to take the New Jersey Path train into Manhattan. The cost of hotel plus Path train tickets is much less than the cost of a Manhattan Hotel and it only takes... more

There were so many bad things about the place I'm not even sure where to start. The front desk staff I dealt with really has no clue about hospitality. Housekeeping left our room OPEN after cleaning it one day (we stayed 6 nights). Repeated calls to the manager went unanswered until I called the Best Western national customer support (which... more

We just returned from a 4 day stay June 17th - 21st. Our main purpose was a family trip to NYC. We wanted a hotel near Amtrak as we took the train from Richmond, Va and the hotel offered a free shuttle from Penn Station to the hotel. We also wanted a free breakfast. THe hotel delivered in those aspects.... more

The hotel is clean, the room is small, but has a fridge and coffee maker. Check in and check out were super fast. We had two problems. We wanted a roll-away, and when making the reservation through Hotels.com we were assured that they will provide roll-away. The hotel refused rollaway, because the room is too small. The worse problem was... more

I used this hotel as a base to visit to NYC. Room was clean and comfortable. The hotel is a 10 mins walk to Penn Station and the PATH trains a very frequent. The only downside is Newark, is the area where the hotel is located does not offer much to a tourist. more