I used to eat at Mario's in Oyster Bay until I tried Fanatico 8 months ago. I've never been back to Mario's since then. The food is great and reasonably priced. The owners are definiatly in the business of making money, no doubt...No refills on soda, portions not as big as they could be- but overall you do get your... more

We have been here 2 times and each time we came our food all came out at totally different times and was cold. Complaints to the waiter do nothing because they always seem to be running around or talking to each other and don't care at all. My wife's dish came out 15 minutes after everyone else at the table... more

excelle more

best salad dressing! more

Fanatico is an extraordinary Italian bistro in a very ordinary supermarket plaza. I was originally attracted to the intriguing facade, and so peeked in to find a beautifully designed interior. Since I was looking for something out of the ordinary LI-diner for lunch, this seemed like a good prospect, even though I wasn't really in the mood for Italian food.... more