We stayed for 1 night in September for pre-cruise. We booked the hotel thru the Holiday Day Inn website, and requested for a room away from the elevator (from the reviews here about the noise) and 6th floor and up. However, we got a room that's on the 5th floor, right across the elevator! We requested a room change but was told that the only room that's away from the elevator has no view of the port...so we stayed.
The hotel room is decent, great for a 3 star hotel. Sheets & the washroom are clean, about 30 channels on TV, and got all sorts of things you'd expect ie. coffee maker, safe, phones, etc. However, one of the phones didnt work but there're 2 in the room so that's ok. Also, one of the lights didn't work so it made the room darker.
Although we stayed right across from the elevator, the noise didn't bother us at all - just a slight "ding" sound when it arrives. However, I agree with others that the doors are very noisy when shut, and the walls are very thin that you can hear your neighbours.
However the real noise is from the traffic below - at 5th floor with windows shut, I'd still hear the cars passed by below...as well, there was noise from the toilet - as if it flushed by itself. Had to close the lid & bathroom door...took a long time to fall asleep.
If noise didnt bother you, this is a great place to stay. Price is reasonable, and the location is great - Bayside is just across the street..2 minute walk. Staff were very friendly and helpful too! $23 tips included for a cab ride from MIA.
On safety, it's better than expected - it was a concern since we were 3 female travelling. But we arrived at around 6pm and went to Bayside, walked back at around 9pm...the market & street were lively with lots of ppl still, so dont need to worry about walking back at night. However, you do see homeless ppl on the street (as with every cities' downtown) but it's not as scary as I thought.
All in all, a great place for pre-cruise but mind the noise! Would recommend staying at least higher than 5th floor.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.